Silmaril Awards 2023: Most Nefarious Villian WINNER

I am so sorry, I’ve really slacked off, and this is my first time hosting too. But I see no reason to change. The Fantasy Times has already covered the ceremony, which happened early this morning, so I’m just going to steal their article and post it here. I’ll do better next year I promise. If I get invited back that is.

Award Presenter Confusion Leads to Strange Flirtation

I arrive at the Villain Awards ceremony and take my seat in the press box. I am surprised at how civilized the crowd is. Though I guess I shouldn’t be, as villains seem to have the most impeccable manners.

Gentle murmurs of conversation hush as a woman clothed all in white steps onto the stage with a red envelope in her hands. “Our Dark Lord appears to be a no show. But the awards must go on. As the first ever to be awarded this prestigious award, it is my honor to present this years Silmaril for Most Nefarious Villain.”

The crowd gasps at the White Witch’s announcement. Then a man strides on stage. He has long hair of purest silver and a tunic fit for a king. He addresses Jadis, “Who is it that has not shown up?”

“Lord Sauron, naturally. He always hosts this award, but he’s skipped out this year. No giant fiery eye anywhere to be seen.”

The man shifts and the crowd can see that he is carrying a Silmaril case. “Is this fiery eye the only form he can take?”

Jadis steps back. “No, of course not, but I don’t see any spiky suits of armour walking around either. What’s it to you anyway, Son of Adam?”

The newcomer pulls back his hair revealing his pointed Elven ears. “I am no Son of Adam. I have been awake since before the breaking of the first silence. And truly I tell you that Sauron can take another form, one that is pleasing to both men and elves. A form that would deceive even the likes of you Jadis.”

The White Witch leans in closer to the stranger. “Who are you?”

The shining Elf turns to face the audience. “I go by many names. Some of you know me as Mairon, The Second age knew me as Annatar. But you,” he turns back to face Jadis, “my dear White Witch, you can call me Sauron.”

Jadis leans in closer, “It really is you! I did’t know you could look so hot.” She stroked his shoulder, “You know we could be a real power couple if we teamed up. Have I ever mentioned that my origin story involves magic rings?”

The Dark Lord pulls her closer. “Indeed, with the ring to the wood between the worlds I could rule all universes.”

“Yes, the Dark Lord and the White Queen.”

He reaches out as if to caress her face but strikes her instead. “Fool, there is only one to rule them all. How dare you consider yourself my equal. You couldn’t even put down that bothersome lion.”

Jadis’s already pale face loses all color save for the red welt growing on her left cheek. She drops the red envelope as she flees the stage.

Sauron bends over and picks up the envelope. “Now that I have reclaimed my rightful place as awards presenter Let’s find out who the winner is.”

Lord Sauron makes a show of placing the Silmaril case on the podium and dramatically opens the red envelope. “With forty out of one hundred and fifty-four, the Most Nefarious Villian is a man after my own villainous soul. No sad back story, no righteous justification. Just pure evil. Your 2023 Most Nefarious Villain is Prince Humperdink from the novel The Princess Bride.”

The crowd erupts into boos and cheers, as the villains in attendance express their admiration for and their jealousy of the evil Prince Humperdink. Prince Humperdink is exuberant as her runs up on stage. He graces Sauron with a bow as the Dark Lord places the Silmaril around his neck.

Humperdink straightens and holds the shining jewel in his hand. “Thank you to everyone who voted for me. At the start of my story I was just a vain, spoiled Prince who wanted to punish Guilder for their princess’s baldness. But over the course of my arc I learned how to commit truly heinous acts. And the best part is that, unlike most of you out there,” Humperdink swept a hand before him indicating the audience, “I lived to plot revenge.”

Humperdink took a breath like he was about to start a longer speech but Sauron cut him off. “And that is all we have time for this year. Congratulations Humperdink, and to those that didn’t win. Better luck next year.”

Awards Schedule by Ceremony.

Monday, September 18: Most Magnificent Dragon – Jenelle Leanna Schmidt
Tuesday, Septemeber 19: Most Nefarious Villain – C.O. Bonham (You are here)
Wednesday, September 20: Most Devoted Couple – Book Shire
Thursday, September 21: Most Wayward Soul – E. E. Rawls
Friday, September 22: Most Silver Tongue – The Grim Writer
Saturday, September 21: Most Epic Heroine – Catherine Hawthorn
Monday, September 25: Most Majestic Ruler – DJ Edwardson
Tuesday, September 26: Most Faithful Friend – JL Mbewe
Wednesday, September 27: Most Mischievous Imp – Bard on pilgrimage
Thursday, September 28: Most Epic Hero – Imperial Scribis
Friday, September 29: Wisest Counselor – Light and Shadows

I hope everyone enjoyed this year’s awards and to those who really think I was being lazy I want you to know—the reporter was me.

A quick shout out to fellow awards host Sarah Pennington. Her newest book, Song of the Selkies, releases today! Go check out her blog for all the good book links and info about the book. https://tpssarahlightshadows.wordpress.com/

Silmaril Awards 2023 Villain Finalists and voting link.

Welcome back to the Nefarious Villain award. There were so many nominations and seconds that it took me almost two hours to read and tally them all. And to those of you who got sent to spam, I deeply apologize but worry not—your vote was counted. But it’s still busy and I may be hiding from Captain Hook so here’s another article I swiped from The Fantasy Times. I mean I they interviewed me for the article anyway the least they can do is let me share it.

Will Hook Make Waves Over Awards Snub?

Watching the contestants vie for the coveted Silmaril is always a fun aspect of awards season, but no award provides quite the level of entertainment as does the Villain award. Watching the worst of the worst get simultaneously offended at being nominated, and outraged at not winning is a highlight for many.

As a Journalist I hunted down the award coordinator and got the inside scoop on the counting process.

“Every blogger has their own process for keeping track of the votes. As a first time awards host it was interesting, Getting advice from veterans and also improvising my method. One Vetren award host shared a spread sheet that helped immensely. I have it set up so that I get an email every time someone comments on my blog. I waited until nominations closed and then went through my email deleting emails as I counted Nominations and seconds. That method combined with the spread sheet kept everything pretty organized for me. Then all I had to do was count the seconds to see who had the most. The top five characters to be ‘seconded’ the most times were the finalists.”

As I was taking my notes it occurred to me that there might be a flaw with this system. “What if there are Characters with the same number of nominations?”

“Well, it really only matters if the tie is between fifth and sixth place since only five characters can advance.”

I look at the blogger pointedly. “And was there a tie between fifth and sixth place?” I asked her.

She adverted her gaze and looked down at her watch. “It was a very close race and so many villains got nominated. So yes there were a bunch that got the same number of seconds. But it didn’t matter until it came to fifth place, so I used my one reader vote as a tiebreaker. I had to pick one or the other and I will not tell you who it was between because these are—well, their the bad guys and I don’t need one mad at me.”

She was looking really nefarious at this point and so I let the matter drop and we moved on to revealing the finalists for Most Nefarious Villain. They are:

Capricorn from Inkheart
Prince Humperdink from The Princess Bride
Lord Sero from the City Between series by W.R. Gingell*
Gnag the Nameless from Wingfeather Saga
Bonifer Squoon also from Wingfeather Saga

If you aren’t sure who any of these people are then click their names to be taken to related fan wikis.

*The City Between series has no fan wiki. (This is a grevious oversight and someone should correct it.) So here’s a run down on Lord Sero provided by the one of the other awards hosts:
Lord Sero may cause flowers and plants to grow wherever he steps, but that’s no cause to underestimate him — and misjudging his character could be the last mistake you ever make. He’s the epitome of a powerful noble fae — which is to say that he’s proud, ambitious, manipulative, and continually in the middle of at least one scheme to increase his own personal power and influence. And, like many fae, he’s not particular about who else he happens to hurt in order to achieve that goal — especially if they happen to be those whom he considers “lesser beings” (which is to say, not fae). He manages to have a finger in every pie, whether it’s the Fae Enforcers or the sinister Upper Management, in addition to the numerous other Behindkind under his direct command. His most notable recent scheme is his continual efforts to push his son into the Kingship of Behind so he can be the power behind the throne, and he’ll use any means he has to — whether magical interference, manipulating his son’s friends and companions, or plain old murder — to accomplish his ends.

As long time award followers will know, the nomination process is always open and can easily be double checked by any decently motivated individual so I assure you that this reporter has done her due diligence and confirmed the results. In doing so, I discovered that the tie for fifth place with ten “seconds” each was between Captain Hook of Neverland and Lord Sero from the City Between.

When I contacted the blogger again for comment, this all she would tell me: “Look anyone can see that Lord Sero is the greater Villain. I mean, Hook is just a Grumpy old man who’s being tormented by the universe’s brattiest child.”

When I reached out to Hook to see how he would react his only reply was. “Finally! Someone understands!”

https://www.silmarilawards.com/vote

When you click on the voting link above you will be taken to a form to vote for the finalists in EVERY award. So if you want to read up on the other finalists before you vote then click on the blog links below.

Awards Schedule by Ceremony.

Monday, September 18: Most Magnificent Dragon – Jenelle Leanna Schmidt
Tuesday, Septemeber 19: Most Nefarious Villain – C.O. Bonham (You are here)
Wednesday, September 20: Most Devoted Couple – Book Shire
Thursday, September 21: Most Wayward Soul – E. E. Rawls
Friday, September 22: Most Silver Tongue – The Grim Writer
Saturday, September 21: Most Epic Heroine – Catherine Hawthorn
Monday, September 25: Most Majestic Ruler – DJ Edwardson
Tuesday, September 26: Most Faithful Friend – JL Mbewe
Wednesday, September 27: Most Mischievous Imp – Bard on pilgrimage
Thursday, September 28: Most Epic Hero – Imperial Scribis
Friday, September 29: Wisest Counselor – Light and Shadows

2023 Silmaril Award Nominations [CLOSED]: Most Nefarious Villain.

After years of blogging I am finally a host for the premier award for fantasy characters.

The Silmaril Awards. This year there are eleven categories including one new one called Most Wayward Soul.

I am hosting the nominations and award for The Most Nefarious Villain.

I really wish I could share more. There is so much happening with the awards this year. But it’s labor day and I’m out of town for the weekend so I found this newspaper article to share with you instead. It’s from some obscure news site called: The Fantasy Times.

Shocking awards upset!

It’s that time of year again folks! The tickets are printed, the jewels are shined and the only thing left to decide is who is worthy!

That’s right it’s awards season here in the realms of fantasy, and society is abuzz with the latest news to come out of The City of Kings. Aragorn the King of Gondor has made a stunning announcement, all Narnia Characters are to be awarded honorary Silmarils.

This was announced at a ceremony where King Aragorn awarded a chest of Silmarils to the four high kings and queens of Narnia and bid them to distribute them to their citizens. (I pause to remind the reader that a lot of Narnians already hold Silmarils, so we can assume this won’t be a hard task.) Then when the Pevensies tried to bow to him Aragorn stopped them and said, “My friends you bow to no one.”

That’s the story folks, after years of the Narnians dominating the awards, it’s finally time for other members of Fantasy to get a chance at the most coveted award in all the realms.

Who will be victorious this year?

Your vote will decide!

What are the Silmaril Awards?

The Silmaril Awards are all about celebrating fantasy fiction. But whereas most awards go to authors or books, these awards go to the characters themselves!

Started in 2016, these awards are a four week online celebration of all that’s best in fantasy literature. There are several awards in various categories given every year.

The characters who receive them have to be from books in the fantasy genre.

Characters cannot receive the same award more than once. These are lifetime awards.

Past Nefarious Villain winners include:

Tolkien and now Narnian characters are not eligible to be nominated. Instead, they’ll be the ones presenting the awards. 

Nominations are submitted in the comments of each of the host blogs.

Anyone can submit a nomination and you can second (and third and fourth, etc.) any number of nominations besides your own.

After the nomination period (lasting one week), the five characters receiving the most nominations will make it onto the ballot and you’ll have one week to vote. After the votes are tallied, the winners will be announced, one per day, over the final two weeks of the awards.

The dates for this year’s awards are:

Nominations week — Sept 4-8

Voting week — Sept 11-15

Awards ceremonies — Sept 18-29

Quick Reminders:

  • No Tolkien or Narnia Characters
  • Book characters only (Movies don’t count unless the book came first.)
  • Only fantasy characters are allows (No sci-fi, adventure, mystery ect…)
  • Leave your nomination as a comment State the character’s name and what book they’re from.
  • Second other’s nominations by replying “I second” to their comment.
  • These are lifetime awards please check the pst winners above before nominating.

So, Who do you think the most Nefarious Villain is?

Nominate them now!

Nominate more at the blogs below:

Most Magnificent Dragon – Jenelle Leanna Schmidt
Most Nefarious Villain – C.O. Bonham (You are here)
Most Devoted Couple – Book Shire
Most Wayward Soul – E. E. Rawls
Most Silver Tongue – The Grim Writer
Most Epic Heroine – Catherine Hawthorn
Most Majestic Ruler – DJ Edwardson
Most Faithful Friend – J L Mbewe
Most Mischievous Imp – Bard on Pilgrimage
Most Epic Hero – Imperial Scribis
Wisest Counselor – Light and Shadows