2023 Silmaril Award Nominations [CLOSED]: Most Nefarious Villain.

After years of blogging I am finally a host for the premier award for fantasy characters.

The Silmaril Awards. This year there are eleven categories including one new one called Most Wayward Soul.

I am hosting the nominations and award for The Most Nefarious Villain.

I really wish I could share more. There is so much happening with the awards this year. But it’s labor day and I’m out of town for the weekend so I found this newspaper article to share with you instead. It’s from some obscure news site called: The Fantasy Times.

Shocking awards upset!

It’s that time of year again folks! The tickets are printed, the jewels are shined and the only thing left to decide is who is worthy!

That’s right it’s awards season here in the realms of fantasy, and society is abuzz with the latest news to come out of The City of Kings. Aragorn the King of Gondor has made a stunning announcement, all Narnia Characters are to be awarded honorary Silmarils.

This was announced at a ceremony where King Aragorn awarded a chest of Silmarils to the four high kings and queens of Narnia and bid them to distribute them to their citizens. (I pause to remind the reader that a lot of Narnians already hold Silmarils, so we can assume this won’t be a hard task.) Then when the Pevensies tried to bow to him Aragorn stopped them and said, “My friends you bow to no one.”

That’s the story folks, after years of the Narnians dominating the awards, it’s finally time for other members of Fantasy to get a chance at the most coveted award in all the realms.

Who will be victorious this year?

Your vote will decide!

What are the Silmaril Awards?

The Silmaril Awards are all about celebrating fantasy fiction. But whereas most awards go to authors or books, these awards go to the characters themselves!

Started in 2016, these awards are a four week online celebration of all that’s best in fantasy literature. There are several awards in various categories given every year.

The characters who receive them have to be from books in the fantasy genre.

Characters cannot receive the same award more than once. These are lifetime awards.

Past Nefarious Villain winners include:

Tolkien and now Narnian characters are not eligible to be nominated. Instead, they’ll be the ones presenting the awards. 

Nominations are submitted in the comments of each of the host blogs.

Anyone can submit a nomination and you can second (and third and fourth, etc.) any number of nominations besides your own.

After the nomination period (lasting one week), the five characters receiving the most nominations will make it onto the ballot and you’ll have one week to vote. After the votes are tallied, the winners will be announced, one per day, over the final two weeks of the awards.

The dates for this year’s awards are:

Nominations week — Sept 4-8

Voting week — Sept 11-15

Awards ceremonies — Sept 18-29

Quick Reminders:

  • No Tolkien or Narnia Characters
  • Book characters only (Movies don’t count unless the book came first.)
  • Only fantasy characters are allows (No sci-fi, adventure, mystery ect…)
  • Leave your nomination as a comment State the character’s name and what book they’re from.
  • Second other’s nominations by replying “I second” to their comment.
  • These are lifetime awards please check the pst winners above before nominating.

So, Who do you think the most Nefarious Villain is?

Nominate them now!

Nominate more at the blogs below:

Most Magnificent Dragon – Jenelle Leanna Schmidt
Most Nefarious Villain – C.O. Bonham (You are here)
Most Devoted Couple – Book Shire
Most Wayward Soul – E. E. Rawls
Most Silver Tongue – The Grim Writer
Most Epic Heroine – Catherine Hawthorn
Most Majestic Ruler – DJ Edwardson
Most Faithful Friend – J L Mbewe
Most Mischievous Imp – Bard on Pilgrimage
Most Epic Hero – Imperial Scribis
Wisest Counselor – Light and Shadows

69 Comments (+add yours?)

  1. C.O. Bonham
    Sep 09, 2023 @ 11:31:52

    Thank you everyone who nominated and seconded I have tallied the votes and counted every one. We invite you all to come back Monday the 11th to vote in the finalists round.

    Reply

  2. Trackback: 2023 Silmaril Award Nominations CLOSED: Most Mischievous Imp – Bard on Pilgrimage
  3. Trackback: Somebody Let Me Host A Silmaril Award–Most Silver Tongue 2023 Nominations are Open [UPDATE: Nominations Now Closed] – The Grim Writer
  4. Carrie-Anne Thomas
    Sep 08, 2023 @ 21:35:07

    My sister can’t get her comments to post, so on her behalf, I second:

    The King Behind (City Between)
    Lord Sero (City Between)
    The Nightmare (City Between)
    Jekyll (Afterverse)
    Whitlock (Afterverse)
    Dragonwitch (Goldstone Wood)
    Nimiane (100 Cupboards)
    Dr. Phoenix (Ashtown Burials)

    Reply

  5. Sarahreader
    Sep 08, 2023 @ 20:47:50

    I second
    Capricorn
    Gnag the nameless

    Reply

  6. Arthur Ransom
    Sep 08, 2023 @ 20:21:45

    I second Capricorn

    Reply

  7. Christine
    Sep 08, 2023 @ 17:27:19

    The news article was so great! *grins*

    I second:

    The King Behind (City Between)
    Lord Sero (City Between)
    Prince John (Robin Hood)
    Zemenar (Enchanted Forest)
    Witch of the Waste (Howl’s Moving Castle)
    Morgan le Fay (Arthurian Legends)
    Prince Humperdink (Princess Bride)
    Dr. Jekyll (Afterverse)
    Jackson Whitlock (Afterverse)
    Nurse Golightly (Afterverse)
    Brother (Afterverse)
    Captain Hook (Peter Pan)
    Devin (Dragons in our Midst)
    Arramos (Dragons in our Midst)
    Semiramis (Dragons in our Midst)
    The Keeper (Entwined)

    Reply

  8. Brittany
    Sep 07, 2023 @ 22:32:09

    Seconding:
    Gnag
    Cap. Hook
    Opal Koboi
    Skalni
    Capricorn
    Zemenar
    The Ash
    The Alder
    The Dragonwitch
    Hattie
    Achren
    Arawn
    The Horned King
    Devin
    Arramos

    Nominating:
    The Gloamglozer from The Edge Chronicles
    The Raven from The Raven Son Saga
    The Hag from The Raven Son Saga

    Reply

  9. Grace T.
    Sep 07, 2023 @ 19:29:25

    I second:
    Gnag the Nameless
    Lord Sero
    Nimiane
    the Darkness
    Skulni
    the Witch-Queen
    Ar’Molon Uun
    Taravangian

    Reply

  10. Charis
    Sep 07, 2023 @ 13:18:28

    I second:
    the Darkness (Moonscript)
    Nimiane (100 Cupboards)
    Dr. Phoenix (Ashtown Burials)
    King Respen (Blades of Acktar)
    Lady Gisela (KotLC)

    Reply

  11. Melwa
    Sep 07, 2023 @ 10:17:36

    seconding:
    Odium (Rayse)
    Gnag the Nameless
    Bonifer Squoon
    Mordred
    Captain Hook
    Lord Sero
    Opal Koboi
    Prince Humperdink
    Count Rugen
    Morgan Le Faye
    Witch of the Waste

    nominating:
    Taravangian, Sadeas (Stormlight Archive)
    the King Behind (City Between)
    IT (Wrinkle in Time)
    Skulni (Fairest)
    Baron Erondites (Queen’s Thief)
    Staff Venture (Mistborn)
    Prince John (Robin Hood)
    Hugo Bonvilain (Airman)

    Reply

  12. NanJW
    Sep 07, 2023 @ 05:04:35

    I nominate Ar’Molon Uun from The Orb and the Airship, by Jenelle Leanne Schmidt!

    Reply

  13. Iris Dontell
    Sep 06, 2023 @ 21:05:24

    I second Zemenar, Prince Humperdinck, the Mistress, and Davira. And I nominate King Respen from Blades of Acktar by Tricia Mingerink!!

    Reply

  14. Deborah O'Carroll
    Sep 06, 2023 @ 16:22:12

    I second:
    The Time King
    Zemenar
    Lord Sero
    Witch of the Waste

    Reply

  15. abbie1821
    Sep 06, 2023 @ 13:18:51

    I second
    Gnag the Nameless
    Sir Mordred
    The Horned King
    Nimiane
    Dr. Phoenix
    Mrs. Dervish
    Captain Hook
    Capricorn (he reaaallyy should win)
    Count Rugen
    Prince Humperdink
    Lord Deparnieux
Sir Keren
    The Master
    Jonathan Dark
    Grendel
    Morgan Le Fay
    King Lawrence
    Maxi

    I nominate
    Morgarath from Rangers Apprentice

    Reply

  16. Blooming Grace
    Sep 06, 2023 @ 00:31:42

    I second Bonifer Squoon and the Darkness.

    I nominate Lucius/the Dark Knight from the Kingdom Series

    Reply

  17. Jenelle
    Sep 06, 2023 @ 00:10:25

    So happy to have you aboard this year!

    Also, I loved your news article! So fun! Love it!!!!

    Oh boy… villains!

    Seconding:
    Captain Hook
    Gnag the Nameless
    Bonifur Squoon
    The Keeper from Entwined
    Lord Whitlock (Afterverse)
    -Arawn (The Chronicles of Prydain)
    Brother from the Afterverse
    Capricorn (Inkheart)
    Prince Humperdinck
    Amber from Rizkaland

    And I nominate:
    Lady Cavendish (The Aeronaut’s Windlass)
    The Time King (Star Clock Chronicles by EJ Kitchens)
    Uncle Vic (Superhero Rescue Project by HL Burke)
    Davira (Ilyon Chronicles Jaye L Knight)
    Zemenar (Enchanted Forest Chronicles by Patricia C Wrede)
    Lord Sero (City Between)
    Witch of the Waste (Howl’s Moving Castle)
    Ra’aba (Dragonfriend series)
    Prince Langston (Green Princess trilogy by HL Burke)

    Reply

  18. DJ Edwardson
    Sep 05, 2023 @ 18:23:53

    Great to have you hosting!

    I second Capricorn and Grendel.

    Reply

  19. Sara
    Sep 05, 2023 @ 15:02:58

    Clarification: I realized I mispelled the dragon I nominated above. His name is Idric, not Idris.

    Reply

  20. Alaina
    Sep 05, 2023 @ 12:15:19

    Seconding Lady Gisela.

    Reply

  21. Sara
    Sep 05, 2023 @ 02:21:37

    I second Amber from The Rizkaland Legends
    The Mistress from The Austen Fairy Tale
    Hans from The Austen Fairy Tale

    Reply

  22. Eruanna1875
    Sep 04, 2023 @ 23:50:52

    I nominate:
    The Master (The Sisters Grimm)
    The Unman (The Space Trilogy)
    The Ash and the Alder (Phantastes)
    Jonathan Dark (Something Wicked This Way Comes)
    Grendel (Beowulf)
    Morgan Le Fay (Arthurian legends)
    King Lawrence (Darien’s Rise)
    The Erlking (Gilded)
    Maxi (Ashtown Burials)

    I second:
    Bonifer Squoon, Yurgen, and Gnag the Nameless
    Humperdinck and Rugen
    Capricorn
    Nimiane
    Doctor Phoenix
    Whitlock
    Captain Hook
    The Horned King
    Mordred
    Brother
    Deparnieux and Keren

    Reply

  23. Katie_home_fry
    Sep 04, 2023 @ 22:38:54

    I second
    Capricorn
    Gnag the nAMLESS
    Bonifer Squoon
    Captain Hook

    I Nominate
    Lord Deparnieux (Rangers Apprentice)
    Sir Keren (Rangers Apprentice)

    Reply

  24. Sarah
    Sep 04, 2023 @ 21:18:14

    I second:

    Odium
    The Keeper
    Cythraul
    Bonifer Squoon
    Lord Sero
    The Nightmare
    Morbin Blackhawk

    And I nominate:
    Amber from The Rizkaland Legends
    The Dragonwitch from Tales of Goldstone Wood
    The Mistress from The Austen Fairy Tale
    Hans from The Austen Fairy Tale
    The Unseelie King from The Lord of Dreams

    Reply

  25. Chloe the MovieCritic
    Sep 04, 2023 @ 17:38:29

    I nominate:
    The Darkling from the Grishaverse
    Wicked Witch of the West from The Wizard of Oz
    The Witch of the Waste from Howl’s Moving Castle

    I second:
    Prince Humperdinck
    Count Rugen
    Hattie
    Lady Gisela
    Skulni
    Captain Hook (my favorite character to hate!)
    The Horned King

    Reply

  26. Elisabeth S
    Sep 04, 2023 @ 16:22:53

    I second Prince Humperdinck from the Princess Bride, Idris from the Kingdom Chronicles, and Lady Gisela from Keeper of the Lost Cities.

    Reply

  27. Sara
    Sep 04, 2023 @ 15:13:35

    I second Prince Humperdink (Princess Bride)
    I second Hattie (Ella Enchanted)
    I second Liliane (Fairy Tale Enchantress)
    I second Tenebris (Snow Queen series)
    I nominate Idris the dragon, from The Kingdom Chronicles by Deborah Grace White. Particularly Kingdom of Dance.

    Reply

  28. Emma
    Sep 04, 2023 @ 14:37:32

    I second Skulni (Fairest)
    I second Hattie (Ella Enchanted)
    I nominate Vivian (King Arthur and Her Knights by KM Shea)
    I second Capricorn (Inkheart)
    I second Odium (Stormlight Archives)
    I nominate Liliane (Fairy Tale enchantress by KM Shea)
    I nominate Tenebris (The Snow Queen by KM Shea)
    I nominate Carabosso (Fairy Tale enchantress by KM Shea)
    I nominate Lady Gisela Sencen (Keeper of the Lost Cities)

    Reply

  29. Trackback: 2023 Silmaril Awards Nominations are Open! – J.L. Mbewe
  30. Alaina
    Sep 04, 2023 @ 12:49:46

    Seconding Hattie and Humperdinck.

    Reply

  31. Wilderness And Writing
    Sep 04, 2023 @ 12:48:23

    I nominate:

    The Witch-Queen (Stardust)
    Skulni (Fairest)
    Hattie (Ella Enchanted)
    Prince Humperdink (The Princess Bride)
    Count Rugen (The Princess Bride)
    King Claudio (Goose Chase)

    Reply

  32. Alaina
    Sep 04, 2023 @ 12:39:01

    Seconding Morbin Blackhawk.

    Reply

  33. Alaina
    Sep 04, 2023 @ 12:38:28

    Seconding:
    (I am just mentally “ugh”-ing every time I think of these characters. 😝)
    – Brother
    – Gnag
    – Bonifer
    – Nimiane
    – Dr. Phoenix
    – Opal Koboi
    – Dr. Henry Jekyll (Afterverse)
    – Lord Jackson Whitlock
    – Nurse Golightly
    – The Neverwolves
    – Beatrice
    – Neva
    – Mrs. Dervish
    – Captain Hook
    – Yurgen
    – Capricorn

    Reply

  34. housemouse
    Sep 04, 2023 @ 11:57:05

    I nominate Morbin Blackhawk, Garten Longtreader, and Tameeth Seer (Green Ember Series)

    Reply

  35. Amelie
    Sep 04, 2023 @ 11:10:10

    Ugh, yes, Brother, Gnag, and Bonifer are VERY evil. Seconding them! Also seconding Sir Mordred.

    Nominating:

    -Lord Sero (the City Between series by W.R. Gingell)
    -the Nightmare (the City Between series)
    -Nimiane (100 Cupboards)
    -Dr. Phoenix (The Ashtown Burials)
    -Opal Koboi (Artemis Fowl)
    -Dr. Henry Jekyll (the Afterverse)
    -Lord Jackson Whitlock (the Afterverse)
    -Nurse Golightly (the Afterverse)
    -the Neverwolves (the Afterverse)
    -Beatrice (the Afterverse)
    -Neva (the Afterverse)
    -Mrs. Dervish (Outlaws of Time)
    -Captain Hook (Peter Pan)
    -the Darkness (Moonscript)
    -Achren (The Chronicles of Prydain)
    -Arawn (The Chronicles of Prydain)
    -The Horned King (the Chronicles of Prydain)
    -Yurgen (The Wingfeather Saga)

    Reply

  36. Merie Shen
    Sep 04, 2023 @ 10:27:54

    I nominate Vivaine from the Keeper Origins and Sir Mordred from the King Arthur legends, and I second Brother!

    Reply

  37. Kal Tomson
    Sep 04, 2023 @ 10:05:20

    I nominate:
    Devin, Arramos, and Semiremas from Dragons in our Midst
    Seamas from King’s Warrior
    Gnag the Nameless and Bonifer Squoon from Wingfeather Saga

    and I second Capricorn

    Reply

  38. Yakira Goldsberry
    Sep 04, 2023 @ 09:36:57

    I nominate Cythraul from Wayne Thomas Batson’s Meridian Constellation Series.

    Reply

  39. Grace T.
    Sep 04, 2023 @ 09:04:01

    I nominate:
    Odium from Brandon Sanderson’s Cosmere universe
    Brother from the Afterverse
    the Keeper from Entwined (Heather Dixon)
    Capricorn (Inkheart)

    Reply

Leave a comment